ESWL (shock wave lithotripsy): when is it still the right choice?
Breaking stones from outside the body is still a good option for some stones, but it is no longer the best choice for every case.
In short
ESWL breaks stones with shock waves from outside the body, with no scope or cut, and you go home the same day. It suits some kidney stones under about 2 cm that are not very hard, but it clears stones less completely than ureteroscopy, and more than one session may be needed. The choice depends on the stone's size, position and hardness, and on you.
What ESWL is
A machine outside the body sends focused shock waves to the stone and breaks it into small pieces, which pass in the urine over days to weeks. There is no scope and no cut. It is usually done without a general anaesthetic, with pain relief, and you go home the same day.
Dr. Meshref has worked with ESWL since the start of his career, and co-authored a 1992 published study on treating ureteric stones with it.
When it still makes sense
- Small and medium kidney stones, usually under about 2 cm, especially in the upper and middle parts of the kidney.
- Some stones in the upper ureter.
- Stones that are not very hard, as shown on a CT scan.
- Patients who prefer to avoid an anaesthetic and a scope, and accept that more than one session may be needed.
When other options are better
- Large stones: PCNL is usually better.
- Very hard stones, or certain stone types such as cystine.
- Some lower-pole kidney stones, where fragments struggle to drain.
- Significant obesity, because the distance from skin to stone weakens the shock waves.
- When you need the stone cleared quickly and reliably.
ESWL is not done in pregnancy, with an untreated urine infection, with blood thinners that have not been managed, or when there is a blockage below the stone that would stop fragments passing.
A balanced comparison
ESWL is less invasive, but stone clearance after it is generally lower than after flexible ureteroscopy, and some patients need more sessions or another procedure later. Ureteroscopy needs an anaesthetic, and a temporary stent is often left afterwards.
Guidelines list both as options for many kidney stones under 2 cm. Dr. Meshref discusses which suits your stone after seeing the scan, based on its size, position and hardness, and on your circumstances.
Possible risks
- Blood in the urine for a day or two.
- Bruising or soreness of the skin where the shock waves entered.
- Colicky pain while the fragments pass.
- Fragments can collect in the ureter and block it, sometimes needing a procedure to clear them.
- A urine infection.
- The stone may not break up enough, so more sessions or another procedure may be needed.
- Rarely, bleeding around the kidney.
Dr. Meshref goes through the risks that apply to you before you decide.
When to get urgent care
Go to the nearest emergency department straight away, then let the clinic know, if you have any of these:
- Fever, shivering or rigors. A blocked kidney with infection is an emergency.
- Severe pain that is not relieved by the painkillers you were prescribed.
- You cannot pass urine.
- Heavy bleeding in the urine, or clots.
- Vomiting that stops you keeping fluids down.
Do not wait for a WhatsApp reply or for your next appointment.
This page is general information and does not replace a medical visit. Your doctor decides on the right treatment after seeing you.
Patient information from the clinics of Dr. Alaa Meshref.
References
International clinical guidelines and key studies. We follow them and adapt them to each patient.
- EAU Guidelines on Urolithiasis · European Association of Urology (EAU)
- Surgical Management of Kidney and Ureteral Stones: AUA Guideline · American Urological Association (AUA)
- Renal and ureteric stones: assessment and management (NG118) · National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE)
Frequently asked questions
What happens at the first visit?
We listen to your complaint and review your tests and scans. When needed, Dr. Meshref does an abdominal and pelvic ultrasound of the kidneys, bladder and prostate himself; for most patients this is included in the consultation at no extra charge. Uroflowmetry and transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) are done when needed and are charged separately. He then explains your condition and the next step. Prepare for your visit: what to bring
Is ESWL painful?
It can be uncomfortable during the session, so pain relief is given. Colicky pain can occur while the fragments pass.
How many sessions will I need?
It depends on the stone. Some people need one session, others need more.
Is ESWL better than ureteroscopy?
Not always. ESWL is less invasive; ureteroscopy usually clears the stone more completely. The choice depends on the stone and on you.
Who should not have ESWL?
Pregnant women, and people with an untreated urine infection, unmanaged blood thinners, or a blockage below the stone. It may also not suit large or very hard stones.